Back to articles

Providing a home for free to a company director as part of its remuneration?

September 27, 2024

Documenting well is the message. Better late than never ! The free provision of a (holiday) home or a flat by a company to its manager is and remains an interesting tax optimisation technique. However, it is viewed with suspicion by the tax authorities. The discussion always revolves around the question whether the costs relating to such home supported by the company can be considered as tax-deductible business expenses.

Providing a home for free to a company director as part of its remuneration?

1. What is it about?

In order to prove that the costs relating to the company’s home can be regarded as a tax-deductible professional expense, the company must demonstrate in particular that the costs were incurred or borne in order to obtain or retain taxable income (the so-called finality condition).

Broadly speaking, two arguments are used in this respect : on the one hand, the remuneration theory and, on the other hand, the capital gains theory (in particular for real estate acquired in full ownership by the company).

Both arguments have since been subject of a multitude of case law, in which the deductibility of such costs is sometimes accepted and sometimes rejected.

A careful analysis of this case law shows that while both the remuneration theory and the capital gains theory do stand in principle, the taxpayer often fails to substantiate these theories in fact. In other words, the mere assertion that a property is made available (whether for free or not) by way of remuneration of the company manager or that it was purchased with a view to a potential long-term capital gain is not sufficient.


2. The added-value theory

In the case of the added-value theory, it will have to be demonstrated concretely that the company had the intention of realising a capital gain on the property at the time of purchase.

This intention is best recorded within the company at the time of purchase. If this was not done, this intention can equally be proven on the basis of presumption.

For example, the intention could be inferred from the fact that there is an investment in full ownership rather than mere usufruct. If the company has made similar investments in the past on which a capital gain was effectively realised, it will also be possible to argue that the new investment was made with the same intention. The Court of Appeal of Ghent recently confirmed the deductibility of the costs relating to a well-defined real estate property after the company had demonstrated, based on a set of factual elements, that it has an actual and regular business activity of buying and selling real estate.


3. The remuneration theory

n the case of the remuneration theory, it must be demonstrated that the benefit granted (consisting of the provision of the property) is part of the company’s remuneration policy and corresponds to actual performance by the manager. In the absence of such evidence, there will be a (non-deductible) liberality on the part of the company.

Recent case law shows that the following elements may be decisive :

  • the manager performs services for the company which result in a constant and substantial flow of income for the company;
  • for those services, the manager receives, in addition to the payment in kind consisting in making the accommodation available free of charge, a pecuniary payment and a number of other payments in kind;
  • the remuneration in kind is recorded in the minutes of and approved by the General Meeting as part of the manager’s remuneration package;
  • the remuneration in kind is mentioned on the individual sheet no. 281.20 drawn up in the name of the manager, who is taxed on it for personal income tax purposes;
  • the remuneration in kind is reflected in the annual accounts (entry in the profit and loss account).


4. Carefully documenting your remuneration policy is and remains the message

A lot of companies only started documenting their remuneration policy after learning about this recent case law.

The fact that this was not yet done at the time of the purchase of the property does not prevent such evidence from being provided for later assessment years.

As a result, it is perfectly possible that the deductibility of the costs for financial year x will be finally rejected in the absence of a substantiated remuneration policy, while the deductibility of these costs for financial year x + 1 will be accepted if the company has since documented its remuneration policy in accordance with recent case law. This is where the remuneration theory differs fundamentally from the capital gains theory.

Thus, the importance of a carefully documented remuneration policy cannot be underestimated. Even companies that have paid insufficient attention to this in the past are warned to remedy this : better late than never!

If you would like more information on this subject, please do not hesitate to contact our specialists at info@be.Andersen.com or +32 (0)2 747 40 07.

tags
added-value theory, company's remuneration policy, deductibility of the costs, document your remuneration policy, providing a home for free, providing a home for free to a company director, remuneration, remuneration policy, remuneration theory, tax optimisation technique, tax-deductible business expenses

Discover more about this topic?

I am looking for a specialist in

See more articles

Court of Justice Sets Limits on Brussels Airbnb Rules, Relaxation to Follow in 2027

18.11.2026

•

Urban Planning and Environmental Law, Real Estate, Renting and Co-ownership, Andersen in Belgium

Court of Justice Sets Limits on Brussels Airbnb Rules, Relaxation to Follow in 2027

A prior authorisation scheme for short-term rentals is not contrary to EU law, but only if it is truly necessary and the procedure provides the operator with sufficient safeguards. This was the ruling of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on 22 October 2026 in the Smartflats case. It is now up to the Brussels Court of Appeal to determine whether the Brussels system meets these criteria. In the meantime, more flexible rules will enter into force on 1 January 2027.

Read the article »
New rules tighten requirements for sustainability claims in the real estate sector

05.11.2026

•

Real Estate, Renting and Co-ownership, Andersen in Belgium

New rules tighten requirements for sustainability claims in the real estate sector

Sustainable, green, energy-efficient or even climate-neutral: these terms have become commonplace in real estate communications. From the end of September, however, the use of such claims will be subject to stricter rules. The new rules aim to better protect consumers against misleading environmental claims. For businesses, the message is clear: commercial communications will need to be more precise.

Read the article »
Belgium imposes new workplace regulations

05.11.2026

•

Employment Law, Andersen in Belgium

Belgium imposes new workplace regulations

Employers must make sure that their internal policies are up date according to Belgium’s PIA and prepare for a stricter time registration obligation.

Read the article »
No Exact Correlation Required Between Expenses Relating to a Holiday Residence and Benefits in Kind

03.11.2026

•

Tax Law, Andersen in Belgium

No Exact Correlation Required Between Expenses Relating to a Holiday Residence and Benefits in Kind

In its judgment of 18 June 2026, the Belgian Court of Cassation settled an important question concerning the deductibility of expenses incurred in making a holiday residence available to a company director: must these expenses be capped at the amount of the benefit in kind (BIK) taxed in the hands of the director? The Court answered in the negative.

Read the article »