The Justice of the Peace of Ixelles was recently asked whether the winter moratorium, provided for in the Brussels Housing Code, entered into force by the ordinance of 22 June 2023 in the Brussels Capital Region, does not violate the European Convention on Human Rights (hereafter ECHR), and more specifically Article 1 of the First Protocol. In what follows, we will first briefly explain what exactly this mini moratorium entails, then discuss the judgment of the Justice of the Peace of Ixelles.

The Brussels Housing Code provides for a general moratorium on eviction during the winter months. This means that no evictions may take place between 1 November and 15 March. This measure took effect on 31 August 2023.
There are four limited exceptions to this ban. For example, it is allowed to deviate from the ban on evictions if:
In a first judgment, the judge declared valid the notice that a landlord had given to his tenant on 27 April 2023 and decided that the lease had ended on 31 October 2023.
However, the tenant did not intend to leave the property voluntarily and had also clearly stated his intentions in this regard. As the tenant did not wish to leave voluntarily, the landlord asked the justice of the peace of Ixelles to rule that the moratorium stipulated in the Brussels Housing Code was in breach of article 1 of the First Protocol to the ECHR and consequently not to apply this article and to allow the eviction one month after the service of the judgement. In other words, the landlord wanted the tenant evicted during the winter moratorium.
A court can only apply national rules if they do not conflict with international rules with a direct effect in the domestic legal order. This is what is called “the primacy of international law” and has been accepted by the Supreme Court since its decision of 27 May 1971.
It is up to the court to ensure compliance with this hierarchy and to verify whether the rules expected to be applied do not conflict with higher norms of international law. If these domestic rules and regulations are found to be in conflict with the higher standard, then these internal rules regulations may not be applied.
The ECHR and its additional Protocols have direct effect in our Belgian legal system. This means that the courts must declare any Belgian norm that conflicts with it not applicable.
In this case, more specifically, the landlord called upon a violation of Article 1 of the First Additional Protocol, which protects the right to property.
This article reads as follows:
“Every natural or legal person is entitled to the peaceful enjoyment of his possessions. No one shall be deprived of his possessions except in the public interest and subject to the conditions provided for by law and by the general principles of international law. The preceding provisions shall not, however, in any way impair the right of a State to enforce such laws as it deems necessary to control the use of property in accordance with the general interest or to secure the payment of taxes or other contributions or penalties.”
When a legislator wishes to curtail this right of undisturbed enjoyment of property, it must strike the right balance between the public interest sought by the curtailment and the right to property.
In its decision regarding the conflict of the winter moratorium in the Brussels Housing Code with Article 1 of the First Additional Protocol, the judge relied on the advice of the Council of State on the ordinance in question.
The Council of State considers that the moratorium stipulated in the Brussels Housing Code does not strike a correct balance between the interests of the tenant on the one hand and the interests of the landlord/owner on the other hand, making this measure an excessive restriction on the right on property.
The Justice of Peace of Ixelles follows this advice and concludes that the winter moratorium in Brussels violates Article 1 of the First Additional Protocol to the ECHR. As a result, the relevant article in the Brussels Housing Code should not be applied.
Both tenants and landlords are thus warned that in the future the winter moratorium in the Brussels Capital Region may be declared inapplicable by judges because it may conflict with Article 1 of the First Additional Protocol of the ECHR.
It will remain to be seen to what extent this opinion will continue to be applied by the courts.
If you require more information, please do not hesitate to contact our specialists via info@be.Andersen.com or +32 (0)2 747 40 07.
I am looking for a specialist in

18.11.2026
•Urban Planning and Environmental Law, Real Estate, Renting and Co-ownership, Andersen in Belgium
A prior authorisation scheme for short-term rentals is not contrary to EU law, but only if it is truly necessary and the procedure provides the operator with sufficient safeguards. This was the ruling of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on 22 October 2026 in the Smartflats case. It is now up to the Brussels Court of Appeal to determine whether the Brussels system meets these criteria. In the meantime, more flexible rules will enter into force on 1 January 2027.

05.11.2026
•Real Estate, Renting and Co-ownership, Andersen in Belgium
Sustainable, green, energy-efficient or even climate-neutral: these terms have become commonplace in real estate communications. From the end of September, however, the use of such claims will be subject to stricter rules. The new rules aim to better protect consumers against misleading environmental claims. For businesses, the message is clear: commercial communications will need to be more precise.

05.11.2026
•Employment Law, Andersen in Belgium
Employers must make sure that their internal policies are up date according to Belgium’s PIA and prepare for a stricter time registration obligation.

03.11.2026
•Tax Law, Andersen in Belgium
In its judgment of 18 June 2026, the Belgian Court of Cassation settled an important question concerning the deductibility of expenses incurred in making a holiday residence available to a company director: must these expenses be capped at the amount of the benefit in kind (BIK) taxed in the hands of the director? The Court answered in the negative.